Contract vs Full-Time Salary Comparison
Compare a contract hourly rate against a full-time salary offer. Account for benefits, taxes, and total compensation.
Contract Position
Self-employment tax (Social Security + Medicare = 15.3%)
Full-Time Position
Counted in total compensation only. Paid time off is already part of the salary, so it does not change the verdict.
Comparison
Compares contract income after SE tax and health insurance with salary after payroll tax plus 401(k) match and other benefits, both before income tax. Health insurance is treated as equal on both sides. Time off is reflected in the contractor's weeks per year.
Contract
Full-Time
How to Compare Contract and Full-Time Offers
A $75/hour contract rate and a $100,000 salary are not directly comparable. Full-time employees receive benefits worth 20-40% of their salary: employer-paid health insurance (~$6,000-$15,000/year), 401(k) matching (~3-6% of salary), paid time off (15-25 days), dental/vision, life insurance, disability coverage, and employer-paid payroll taxes (7.65%). Contractors pay their own self-employment tax (15.3%), health insurance, and retirement contributions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What contract rate equals a given salary?
A common rule of thumb is to divide the annual salary by 1,000 to get an equivalent hourly contract rate. A $100,000 salary roughly equals a $100/hour contract rate. This accounts for benefits, self-employment taxes, and non-billable time. For a more precise comparison, use this calculator with your specific benefits package.
What about job security and stability?
This calculator focuses on financial comparison, but job stability has real value. Full-time roles typically offer severance packages, unemployment insurance eligibility, and predictable income for mortgage applications. Contract work offers flexibility and often higher gross pay, but with gaps between contracts and no safety net. Consider assigning a dollar value to stability based on your risk tolerance.
Are there tax advantages to either arrangement?
Contractors can deduct business expenses (home office, equipment, travel, professional development) that employees cannot. The QBI deduction can reduce taxable income by 20%. However, contractors pay the full 15.3% self-employment tax. On balance, the tax situation depends heavily on your deductible expenses - contractors with high legitimate expenses may pay less in taxes despite higher gross income.